Choose

[gridfaniker]

where's mike phipps??


these lists blow

[Southern_Yankee]

Originally Posted by vpkozel

It truly is amazing how much of a genius you are on every topic you choose to have an opinion on.

you outta see it when he raves on about the pleasures of man-on-man sex.

[Pi.]

Originally Posted by vpkozel

If anyone on this board would have a wealth of first hand knowledge of that, it would be you.

Have you actually read this thread? Like Collin, you always seem oblivious when you are making a fool of yourself.

[Pi.]

Originally Posted by Southern_Yankee

you outta see it when he raves on about the pleasures of man-on-man sex.

You can leave the thread now. Nobody found that funny.

[Piper]

Originally Posted by Pi.

Here is a list from ESPN.com that may be slightly less biased than the Panther forum on TBR.

And here's another. Hall of Famers choose Manning over Brady

Voting results

For Peyton Manning: (13½ votes)
Troy Aikman (Class of ’06), George Blanda (’81), Len Dawson (’87), Dan Fouts (’93), Bob Griese (’90), Sonny Jurgensen (‘83), Jim Kelly (’02), Warren Moon (’06), Joe Namath (‘85), Clarence (Ace) Parker (’72), Fran Tarkenton (’86), Y.A. Tittle (’71), Charley Trippi (’68). Joe Montana (’00) (second half)

For Tom Brady: (2½ votes)
Terry Bradshaw (’89), John Elway (’04), Joe Montana (first half)

Abstain: Dan Marino (’05), Bart Starr (’77), Roger Staubach (’85), Steve Young (’05)

[Pi.]

Originally Posted by Piper

And here's another. Hall of Famers choose Manning over Brady

That's great but I was debating VP's statement that Brady isn't top 5 all time already. I agree Manning is also. Manning also has had 3 more seasons to compile stats and awards.

I think when it is all said and done, if Brady stays healthy he will be the best ever with Manning a close second. If not I see them as 1-2 regardless.

[Piper]

It's hard to judge a career that's still going, we tend to overrate what we just saw. I'm not sure Favre deserves top 4, and Graham is far higher than 14. I'd put them both top 7 lets say, with Montana, Elway, Marino, Favre and Unitas. I'd probably put them both above Favre.

[vpkozel]

Originally Posted by Pi.

Have you actually read this thread? Like Collin, you always seem oblivious when you are making a fool of yourself.

If you remove one of the best QBs of all time for a year, I would expect a really crappy season. If you removed Brady, you still go 11-5.

When pretty much every other QB (other than Montana and Staubach, both of whom were on superior teams and replaced by outstanding QBs) on these lists left, their teams went in the tank.

[Powerbait]

Jay Fiedler is the man!

Also, where is Jake Delhomme on this list?

[Pi.]

Originally Posted by vpkozel

If you remove one of the best QBs of all time for a year, I would expect a really crappy season. If you removed Brady, you still go 11-5.

When pretty much every other QB (other than Montana and Staubach, both of whom were on superior teams and replaced by outstanding QBs) on these lists left, their teams went in the tank.

Clueless.

[Powerbait]

All of this will be irrelevant in 5 years when Chad Henne has 4 super bowl rings.